Farmers Can Beat Analysis Paralysis with the 80:20 Rule
Winter is the season of data analysis for farmers. It is a chance to look at the data from the past year and understand what happened in order to improve next season. However, enthusiasm can turn into analysis paralysis when farmers get bogged down in the data. Growers risk spending their time and effort making changes that don’t actually move them towards their goals.
How can growers focus on what’s important and leave the rest? One strategy is the Pareto principle, better known as the 80:20 rule, which helps set priorities.
What is the 80:20 rule?
In 1895, Vilfredo Pareto observed that in many cases, roughly 80% of consequences come from 20% of causes. His 80:20 rule has been applied to trends in wealth distribution, quality control, public health, and more.
It may also apply to a farm business. For instance, farmers may observe some or all of the following:
- 20% of crops account for 80% of sales
- 20% of customers account for 80% of transactions
- 20% of inputs account for 80% of costs
The 80:20 rule will not apply in every situation. However, it can help businesses identify what has the biggest impact on their success and focus on improving those areas first. By prioritizing these areas, changes are likely to have a larger impact.
An 80:20 rule example
To show how the 80:20 rule may apply to crop profitability, we can use this hypothetical data set showing total costs and sales for a mix of crops:
A farmer’s first instinct may be to look for the least profitable crops. Here there may be chances to raise prices, reduce costs, or increase yields. In this example, the farmer may see cucumbers and eggplant as the most important crops to improve, because they are not profitable:
However, when we apply the 80:20 rule to sales dollars by crop, we see that cucumbers and eggplant make up only 2% of the farm’s total income:
Using the 80:20 rule, the farmer may instead choose to improve watermelon sales. They account for 14.80% of total sales but have a lower margin than other top sellers:
Let’s imagine the farmer only has the resources to make one of two changes:
- Scenario A: increase sales of eggplant and cucumbers by 25% (through price and yield increases)
- Scenario B: increase sales of watermelons by 10% (through price and yield increases)
The sales increase in Scenario B is more modest, but it has a greater effect on the farmer’s bottom line:
The 80:20 rule may help this farmer confidently focus on Scenario B, which should yield a greater impact on the farm.
Don’t abandon the other 80
Joseph M. Juran built on Pareto’s original idea to describe the 20% of causes as “the vital few” and the remaining 80% as “the useful many.” While focusing improvements on the top 20% of crops/customers/costs is likely to be impactful, the 80:20 rule does not suggest eliminating the other 80%. Farmers should continue to steward the whole business. But when resources are limited, the 80:20 rule can reveal where efforts are best spent.
As you enter analysis season, can the 80:20 rule help you clarify next year’s priorities?
To discuss data-driven decision-making on your farm, contact Annie Scott, CCD Extension Associate, at annie.scott@uky.edu.